Take a look at these quotes below and write a 500 word piece arguing why you agree or disagree, or perhaps partly agree, with these authors’ comments.
A.N. Wilson (2012), a columnist in the Daily Mail suggests that:
…the effect of the huge increase in immigration in the past decade or so has left millions of us feeling a little shell-shocked. We no longer recognise the country we grew up in. We are increasingly aware that a uniting British culture that evolved over centuries is fragmenting. It is not racist to suggest that our social infrastructure our schools, hospitals and housing stock cannot cope with such enormous numbers of migrants so quickly. The numbers of foreigners settling in this country must be reduced. And one thing which could and should be done immediately is for the Government to ban the use of any language other than English in schools. Until we all speak the same language, there is small hope that we could ever come together and cohere as the new society of the future.
Norman Ginsburg (2014), Professor of Social Policy, London Metropolitan University
One of the most pernicious constructions of migration as a social problem is the notion that migrants, both economic and political, have come with the intention of claiming benefits and using public services, to live off the welfare state at the taxpayer’s expense. This led in the 00s to the passage of legislation to try to prevent asylum seekers using the welfare state, while at the same time preventing them for finding paid employment. The obvious intention was to make life very unpleasant for those in the country and to deter would-be asylum seekers outside the country. But the allegation of welfare ‘abuse’ is also extended to economic migrants, including people from other EU member states, who have been alleged to practice ‘welfare tourism’. A major research project commissioned by the European Commission ICF-GHK (2013) found very little evidence to support the notion that ‘the main motivation of EU citizens to migrate and reside in a different Member State is benefit-related as opposed to work or family-related’ ICF-GHK (2013: v). The project examined the use of public benefits and healthcare services by non-active (i.e. not employed) intra-EU migrants. Despite many requests the British government has been unable to supply evidence of significant intra-EU welfare tourism to the European Commission.
Wilson, A.N. (2012) ‘I no longer recognize the Britain I grew up in’, Daily Mail, 15 December. Available online: www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2248365
Ginsburg, N. (2014) in Isaacs, S et al (2014), ‘Social Problems in the UK: An Introduction’, Routledge
Now write a 500 word piece arguing why you agree or disagree, or perhaps partly agree, with these authors’ comments.
0 of 1 Questions completed
You have already completed the quiz before. Hence you can not start it again.
Quiz is loading…
You must sign in or sign up to start the quiz.
You must first complete the following:
Time has elapsed
Thank you for submitting your answer.
Please ask your teacher to print off a copy of your answer if you would like a copy.
(When you complete this Session you will be able to download a PDF document of possible answers to the question.)
Is migration a social problem?
This response will be reviewed and graded after submission.